Return to Miscellaneous Case Updates

Buried in Documents

Sheilla buried in documentsAugust 10, 2019
Sheilla Dingus

I wanted to get an article out this week.  I really did.  But it’s just been one of those weeks where the documents (and some other interesting leads) continue to accumulate and as soon as I’ve settled on a subject to write about, something new has bumped it down further on the cue.  So–instead of an article, I’m going to give you documents this week.  Lots of documents spanning lots of cases starting with a consolidated brief filed by former Class Counsel to the NFL Concussion Settlement, Gene Locks,  appealing common benefit fee allocations that went primarily to Seeger Weiss.  The brief is accompanied by 13 volumes of supporting appendices spanning 9,891 pages.  You can find all the documents on our Document Cloud folder–or– I’ve linked two of particular interest below.

NFL Concussion Settlement

Joint Opening Brief of Appellants Addressing the Common Benefit Fee Allocation

Amon Gordon Appeal -For details about the Gordon appeal and why it’s of utmost importance to the entire Class, this article will fill you in.

Third Circuit Order requesting briefing as to why the court should hear the appeal.

2019 08 06 Show Cause Order (Text)

Riddell Litigation

The High School and College Players lawsuit was denied class certification this week.

Opinion Denying Class Certification

Opinion Denying Class Certification (Text)

Kelli Ewen v NHL

Kelli Ewen’s lawsuit against the NHL for her husband Todd’s CTE death is moving along.  This week a joint statement was filed, in which the NHL, continues to deny liability, and states intent to fight Ms. Ewen on statute of limitations and LMRA preemption.

Joint Statement

033 Joint Statement (Text)

Also, the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation vacated a conditional transfer order on Friday.  This means the case will not be transferred to Minnesota and will proceed in the Northern District of California.

Lane Johnson v NFLPA

This week Lane Johnson’s remaining LMRDA Claims against NFLPA were dismissed.  We’ve tracked this case extensively and our most recent article on the case elaborated on why they shouldn’t have been.  No word yet regarding whether Johnson plans to appeal.

Opinion Granting NFLPA Motion for Summary Judgment

155 Opinion and Order Granting SJ for NFLPA (Text)

Andre Royal NFL Disability Lawsuit

We detailed Andre Royal’s struggle to receive the NFL disability benefits he should be entitled to regarding his disability that came directly from his football career in a recent article.  After 18-years of stonewalling, he filed a lawsuit against the Disability Plan, NFL, and NFLPA.  This week the NFL Plan responded with an exhibit laden motion to dismiss.

Bert Bell/Pete Rozelle NFL Player Plan Motion to Dismiss

007 0 Board Plan First Motion to Dismiss (Text)

DeMeco Ryans v Houston Texans (turf injury)

This is one of the cases I’ve been tracking but haven’t found time to write about.  For background, you can read this article from Southeast Texas Record.  The case was ordered to arbitration this week.

Opinion Compelling Arbitration

Opinion Compelling Arbitration (Text)


A petition filed Thursday with the National Labor Relations Board by a group called the International Brotherhood of Professional Running Backs seeks to establish a separate union for running backs.  Advocacy for Fairness in Sports is attempting to obtain the documents, but in the meantime, a couple of articles provide some information.
Law360            Bloomberg

Team USA Figure Skating Sexual Abuse

Another lawsuit claiming sexual abuse in Team USA Figure skating has been filed.

John Doe v USA Figure Skating et al Lawsuit

2019 08 02 Original Complaint (Text)

U.S. Women’s Soccer Team Equal Pay Lawsuits

The Women’s Team, led by Alex Morgan, has objected to Hope Solo’s participation in their arbitration and negotiations with U.S. Soccer. This week plaintiffs and defendants filed a joint report with suggested discovery dates, mandates, and other preferences.  I found the preference for arbitration over complex litigation interesting and a bit puzzling.

uswt joint brief

USWT & U.S. Soccer Federation Joint Report

057 0 Joint Report (Text)

Hope Solo, who filed a separate lawsuit seeking equal pay, and wished to participate in the arbitration filed an emergency motion for sanctions.

Reply to Non-Parties Alex Morgan et al's Opposition to Hope Solo's Emergency Motion for Sanctions Pursuant to FRCP Rule 11

066 Reply to Non Parties Alex Morgan Et Al’s Opposition to Hope Solo’s Emergency Motion for Sanctions Pursuant to FRCP Rule 11 (Text)

Saints “No Call” Lawsuits

Several lawsuits were filed regarding the NFC Championship Game “no call” and all but one were removed to federal court and have been dismissed one by one.  LeMon v NFL remains in state court and an appeals court upheld depositions of Roger Goodell and the referees.  The Saints have joined with the NFL in seeking dismissal of the case upon appeal to the Louisiana Supreme Court, but should that fail the league has asked that depositions of the commissioner and officials take place outside Louisiana citing safety concerns.

Defendants Motion for Protective Order

Defendants’ Motion for a Protective Order 8 7 19 (Text)

Hogan v Weymouth/ Chung

Shortly after filing I wrote about the strange lawsuit that arose from unkind comments regarding New England Patriots’ Patrick Chung when he broke his arm in the Super Bowl in February.  Matthew Hogan texted his former friend Matthew Weymouth (who is also a friend of Patrick Chung) some crude comments regarding Chung’s injury. Weymouth was not amused and shared the texts with Chung, who posted them to social media. Hogan filed a lawsuit against both Weymouth and Chung that likely won’t get very far. So far all motions he’s filed have been denied and he apparently took his time in serving the defendants.  You can view the case file here.  After finally receiving service of the lawsuit, Weymouth and Chung responded this week.

Weymouth Motion to Dismiss

037 000 Weymouth Motion to Dismiss (Text)

Declaration of Matthew Weymouth

037 001 Matthew Weymouth Declaration (Text)

Declaration of Patrick Chung

037 002 Patrick Chung Declaration (Text)

Proposed Order

037 003 Proposed Order (Text)

Turner Tenney v FaZe Clan (Esports contract dispute)

Derek Helling wrote about Tenney’s lawsuit against FaZe Clan, alleging that the company exploited inexperienced young players.  FaZe Clan has now filed a countersuit.

FaZe Clan v Turner Tenney Countersuit

001 FazeClan v Tenney Countersuit Complaint (Text)

Phillies v Harrison

This week the Philadelphia Phillies filed a lawsuit to resolve a dispute as to who owns rights to their mascot.  Will Phanatic become a free agent?

Phillies v Harrison Mascot Lawsuit

001 Phillies v Harrison Mascot Lawsuit Original Complaint (Text)

Eric Murdock v United Airlines

You may remember this case when it first broke.  Eric Murdock and a fellow passenger, Brenda Williams, whom he’d never met previously were subjected to horrifying racial discrimination and harassment by a United Airlines flight attendant, according to the original complaint.  This is one of the lawsuits I’d wanted to write about as it progressed and a few volleys ensued, but it settled before I could get it on my cue.  While the settlement amount is confidential, I hope Mr. Murdock and Ms. Williams received a substantial sum to compensate them, at least in part for their ordeal.  I’m a bit late reporting on this but since I hadn’t seen the settlement reported elsewhere, I thought I might as well toss it in.

Stipulation of Voluntary Dismissal (Settlement)

025 Stipulation of Voluntary Dismissal (Text)

Advocacy for Fairness in Sports is a nonprofit dedicated to investigative sports journalism.
Please help us to continue bringing the stories that no one else is reporting by making a small contribution toward our operating costs. Court documents aren’t free, and you can be a difference-maker by helping us to meet the expenses necessary to remain ad-free and provide the coverage you’ve come to expect over the past three years.

Editor at Advocacy for Fairness in Sports | Website

Sheilla Dingus founded Advocacy for Fairness in Sports in October 2016, after a stint with Defenders of the Wall, a New England Patriots based blog where she dived deep into the legal aspects of Deflategate. Along the way, she observed many inequities in sports and felt a need to address some of the under-reported stories in sports law. She draws from her background as a former professional dancer, who like many of the athletes she writes about, took an early retirement due to orthopedic injuries. After a return trip to college she worked for a legal software company, with seven years as a Project Manager and Analyst. She brings her analytical skills to the table in breaking down complex lawsuits, and enjoys pursuing her longtime interest in journalism.

Permanent link to this article: